Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

"Why I skip red lights": Journalist makes the case for cyclists riding through reds; Finish fisticuffs as Benoît Cosnefroy grabs British rider after sprinting incident; Jumbo-Visma pro tests positive + more on the live blog

It's a sunny Thursday here on the live blog where Dan Alexander will be taking you one step closer to the weekend with today's round-up of all that's going on in the cycling world...

SUMMARY

No Live Blog item found.

17 August 2023, 07:47
"Why I skip red lights": Journalist makes the case for cyclists riding through reds

Journalist Sophie Wilkinson has penned a column for the Evening Standard outlining why she believes cyclists should be allowed to ride through red lights (so long as they give pedestrians priority)...

She writes...

I find it is far better is to jump lights — which is why I say make it legal for cyclists to jump red lights and so much more in order to maintain our safety. 

As I always give pedestrians right of way, the only life I risk by jumping a red is my own. Turning left at a junction? I believe it is far safer to do so before the vehicle behind gets the same idea and pulls me under its wheels.

And why shouldn't a bike go through a set of green pedestrian lights when there are simply no pedestrians in sight? 

 Thoughts?

We wouldn't be the first place to allow it. Cyclists in Paris are allowed to at some junctions (much to the surprise of my visit last year, armed with my very British confusion and willingness to wait in a queue, as legions of Lime bike hirers nonchalantly sailed past me and safely through junctions). Likewise it's permitted in some other cities on the continent, while in Idaho cyclists must come to a full stop before proceeding and must yield to other traffic.

> Should cyclists be allowed to ride through red lights? Campaigners split on safety benefits

Last year, Colorado adopted new legislation meaning at a stop sign, cyclists are required to "slow to a reasonable speed" and give way to any motor traffic or pedestrians at the junction before proceeding. On encountering a red traffic light, they have to stop at the junction and give way to any vehicles or pedestrians there before continuing on their way – even if the lights haven't changed.

What do you think? Do you always stop at red lights? Would you like to see a change to the law? Would it make things safer? We'll round up some reaction to the piece next...

17 August 2023, 11:51
Your thoughts on whether cyclists should be allowed to ride (cautiously) through red lights

Just a few comments on this one... let's get cracking and hopefully we're all done in time for tea...

Sriracha: "Of course it is safer for the cyclist to make the left turn before the adjacent HGV does the same. But I don't think having cyclists jump red lights is the answer. Longer term I'd like to see separate lights for cyclists (like the little ones you see in France) that would go green ahead of the main lights, anywhere where there is a cycle box/ASL (which need to be the norm, not the exception)."

Rendel Harris: "While I'd be happy for cyclists to be allowed through red lights in certain situations - left turn on red for example – I think it would be an horrendous mistake to allow them to run reds on pedestrian crossings. Just last night I was watching our bikes outside East Dulwich station whilst Herself picked up some shopping, in five minutes I saw at least a dozen cyclists run through the red at the pelican crossing whilst pedestrians were on it; at least half of them were riding in excess of 20 mph (it's at the bottom of a hill) and had to swerve around people crossing.

"If this is the way people behave when it's totally illegal, I can't see any improvement occurring if it was made legal. Any legislation to allow any leeway for cyclists at lights must remember the hierarchy of road users and have pedestrian safety as its #1 priority."  

neilmck: "In France there will be a little sign with arrows on the traffic light telling you which directions you can go on red. Whether or not there are these signs depends whether or not there is a cyclist working in the local town hall (this can also be determined by looking at the width of the cycle lanes).

"I commute 50km by bicycle everyday in Paris and I generally go through red lights in the outer Parisian region where there is very light traffic and no pedestrians, however I would never do so (except at a signalled junction) in central Paris (there is just too much happening to be safe)."

Kerry Palmer: "It's been legal in some States in the US since 1982... and most of the evidence found it's safer."

Fair few Facebook comments, I'd suggest without actually reading the article in question, missing out completely the idea Sophie suggested it become law... and instead just piling into one great big anti-cycling bingo round. Gives 'em something to do at lunch, I guess...

Morgoth985: "Seems to me that a lot of the objections to the going through red lights idea are along the lines of 'don't break the law, it will just encourage drivers to do the same'. But if it was a change to the HC then it wouldn't be breaking the law.

"Granted, it would be giving some road users a right that others don't have, which might annoy the 'have nots', but too bad, that's actually the idea, and wouldn't be the only instance.  [edit: I meant the extra right is the idea, not the annoyance, although who knows, maybe that would be worth it too!]"

17 August 2023, 15:56
The road bike we should all be riding? The road.cc Podcast + Matt Page takes on the long winding road just to start Paris–Brest–Paris

Here's a quick round up of some of the other stuff around the site this afternoon, starting with Jamie's vid on the 2023 Canyon Endurace...

Elsewhere, we've also got our latest episode of the road.cc Podcast out now wherever you get you podcasts...

road.cc Podcast episode 58

> Around the world without a motor + How to save serious watts with Aerocoach's Xavier Disley on the road.cc Podcast

While Matt Page has penned a piece on why just getting to the start line of Paris-Brest-Paris is a bit of a faff... and we don't mean travel wise...

> The very long road to Paris — just getting to the start line of the legendary Paris–Brest–Paris bike ride is a journey in itself

17 August 2023, 15:37
Primož Roglič wins Vuelta a Burgos stage as Vuelta a España prep continues

More good news for Jumbo-Visma's website to move things on from the past 24 hours...

17 August 2023, 14:45
Scotland's "unluckiest cyclist" wins compensation – after being knocked off his bike for third time
17 August 2023, 14:25
Will the last person to leave Ineos please turn out the lights?
Ben Tulett (Alex Whitehead/SWpix.com)

[Alex Whitehead/SWpix.com]

We touched on Ben Tulett's Ineos exit a bit earlier while trying to work out the absence of Michel Hessmann's positive test from Jumbo-Visma's website. The latest departure means the team has just 15 riders signed up for next season, half of how many are currently on their books.

And while it would mean just needing three of the hideous self-named 4x4s to ferry the entire squad about, one guesses fulfilling a WorldTour calendar with such scarce numbers might be slightly more challenging.

Tao Geoghegan Hart is off to Lidl-Trek, Daniel Martínez to Bora-Hansgrohe, Pavel Sivakov to UAE and Tulett to Jumbo. Of course, the 11 remaining out of contract riders can still extend their stay, but we'd expect some reinforcements soon... unless the 2024 plan is just Pidcock, Bernal, Kwiatkowski and Geraint Thomas to ride all three Grand Tours, with Filippo Ganna and Josh Tarling doing the work of two riders each...

17 August 2023, 13:54
???

I'm not sure what to say about this, to be honest...

Good potential for comment section punning, I guess... 

17 August 2023, 12:52
Eurostar bike booking process branded "farcical"
Eurostar (public domain by Campus France)

> Eurostar bike booking process branded "farcical"

As discussed a bit in the live blog comments...

17 August 2023, 11:15
Do the latest track bikes favour wealthier nations, and how will the UCI respond?
17 August 2023, 10:13
Jumbo-Visma rider Michel Hessmann suspended after positive anti-doping test
Michel Hessmann 2023 Giro d'Italia (Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

(Zac Williams/SWpix.com)

It's been one of those weeks for the sport of cycling...

On Tuesday, former Team Sky and British Cycling doctor Richard Freeman was banned from all sports for four years by UK Anti-Doping (UKAD) for violating its rules by taking possession of Testogel for unnamed riders.

Dr Richard Freeman (picture credit Team Sky)

Then, last night, Jumbo-Visma, the team that has won both Grand Tours so far this year and the last two editions of the Tour de France, announced that a rider on their books had been suspended after an out-of-competition doping test came back positive for a diuretic medicine.

Not that you'd know it from the team's website, where news of Ben Tulett's signing from Ineos Grenadiers and the team time trial success at Vuelta a Burgos is all that's deemed worthy of mention.

Michel Hessmann is the rider involved, the team announcing the news only on social media in a post with replies disabled. The German was part of the line-up that helped Primož Roglič win the Giro, having finished third at Tour de l'Avenir last season, and was last week competing in the road race in Glasgow.

"It concerned an out-of-competition control on 14 June in Germany. The detected product is a diuretic medicine. We await the results of further investigation. Michel has been suspended by the team until further notice," Jumbo-Visma's short social media statement read.

17 August 2023, 09:20
Finish fisticuffs as Benoît Cosnefroy grabs Lewis Askey after sprinting incident

Drama after yesterday's Tour du Limousin sprint, British rider Lewis Askey bearing the brunt of Benoît Cosnefroy's ire... 

Askey later explained he had gone to see the Frenchman to explain what had happened from his viewpoint, adding that they had shaken hands and there is "no bad blood".

Cosnefroy gave his side of the story too... "You have to look at the last 150 metres. It's the game to put me in the box, but from there to put me at the feet of barriers... It's his job to put me in the box, if he does it — there's no problem, but between putting myself in the box so that I don't pass and putting me at the feet of barriers, there is a difference.

Benoît Cosnefroy grabs Lewis Askey (GCN)

"We already take enough risks on the bike, we are often afraid for our lives, and when you see yourself touching the barrier feet, I can tell you that it's scary. The team worked superbly, so I wanted to look for the win and I felt that I had it surely in my legs. no more fear at the finish, that's just it."

17 August 2023, 08:27
Reaction to the Evening Standard red light column

Some reaction to Sophie Wilkinson's column now...

Basel red light study (picture credit VDB)

There are plenty of people placing the emphasis of the discussion around the need to still give way to pedestrians crossing and not put those on foot in danger.

Robin Hawkes replied to Jeremy Vine's tweet: "The 'pedestrian priority' part of this is what most troubles me, as I simply do not see it happening so often in practice."

Another reply suggested it could "increase risk unnecessarily".

Dan is the road.cc news editor and joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan has been at road.cc for four years and mainly writes news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He has hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.

Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, when he's not working you'll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he'll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he's a bit strange like that.

Add new comment

66 comments

Avatar
momove replied to the little onion | 1 year ago
6 likes

Yes, I'd just be happy with the current rules being enforced for drivers running red lights and speeding.

Avatar
lonpfrb replied to momove | 1 year ago
0 likes
momove wrote:

Yes, I'd just be happy with the current rules being enforced for drivers running red lights and speeding.

If road traffic law enforcement is not a national priority (Active Travel etc.) then changing Attitudes is required to improve compliance.

Over to the Department of Culture Media and Sports to act...

Avatar
brooksby | 1 year ago
8 likes

Is this something people have read, yet?

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2023/aug/17/eurostar-derailed-my-effor...

Quote:

Eurostar ... announced bikes could be booked on to services between 07.55 and 15.30 GMT from London to Brussels, and from 07.30 to 19.30 CET from Brussels to London.

Cut out and keep this intelligence because it’s not on the website! And there’s a catch. You can’t request the bike booking until you’ve bought your non-refundable train tickets, and responses to emails take between seven to 10 days. If you’re lucky, you get permission to pay £45 to check your bike in; if you’re not, you’ve got a ticket that’s no use for a cycling holiday. 

Avatar
TheItalianJob replied to brooksby | 1 year ago
5 likes

Yes, it sounds to me like Eurostar could not care less and replied with "whatever" even to the Guardian journalist.

Avatar
momove replied to TheItalianJob | 1 year ago
5 likes

Considering the multiple gigantic suitcases that people can take on Eurostar and other trains, for free, it's disappointing a bike has such a high charge and difficult process.

And the reason it's disappointing is because I'd love to do it and buy a ticket!

Avatar
ROOTminus1 replied to momove | 1 year ago
4 likes
momove wrote:

Considering the multiple gigantic suitcases that people can take on Eurostar and other trains, for free, it's disappointing a bike has such a high charge and difficult process.

And the reason it's disappointing is because I'd love to do it and buy a ticket!

I see opportunity for a business with premises at either end to rent out unmarked bike boxes
"It's just large luggage"
"Oh, what's in there?"
"...OLED TV"

Pages

Latest Comments