Last week, the latest polling for the London mayoral election in May had Conservative Party candidate Susan Hall 25 points behind Sadiq Khan. Hall's campaign will, by many, be remembered for her pre-Christmas claim that her wallet being stolen on the tube was evidence of lawless London, only for it to be returned by a Good Samaritan because she'd in fact "dropped it" — however, with the big day less than two months away, the Tory candidate has ramped up her campaigning, posting a video on social media claiming that "LTNs [low-traffic neighbourhood schemes that prevent drivers rat-running certain roads in residential areas, in a bid to encourage active travel and tackle air and noise pollution] are blocking ambulances".
To make her point, Hall spoke to one emergency services worker...
As the ambulance attendant, Hazel, tells her: "They're not helping at all, get rid of them. Just simply get rid of them." The Ranty Highwayman, an account run by a highway engineer, asked Hall if Hazel's "speaking on behalf of the NHS, the London Ambulance Service, a transport contractor or herself. This is an important point that needs answering."
An important point indeed, especially considering some of the official emergency service communication about LTNs...
In 2021, the London Fire Brigade said low-traffic neighbourhoods have had no impact on response times. LFB said: "LTNs have been part of London's transport strategy since the 1970s. LTNs help to make streets around London easier to walk and cycle on by stopping cars, vans and other vehicles from using quiet roads as shortcuts.
"We haven't yet noticed any impact on our attendance times due to the LTN schemes established in 2020; however, we will continue to monitor their impact at a local level."
And while one year's data does not necessarily reflect long-term trends, particularly in a year after the coronavirus pandemic caused such disruption to peoples lives and routines. However, looking a little further back, Waltham Forest – which has created a number of LTNs in recent years under its Mini Holland programme, saw average response times fall from 5 minutes 2 seconds in 2018 to 4 minutes 54 seconds in 2019 and 4 minutes 43 seconds in 2020 (again, admittedly a pandemic year).
> Pop-up bike lanes don't slow ambulances according to… the ambulance service
Last year, police in Tower Hamlets urged the council not to scrap a Liveable Streets scheme, saying that it has resulted in a reduction in antisocial behaviour-related crime.
One Twitter (X) user who replied to Hall commented: "Here's an ambulance driver driving straight through the filters of an LTN to swiftly get to their destination.
Note: no motor traffic backlog to hold the ambulance up and the driver did not incur a fine as emergency vehicles are exempt, as are buses."
Another reply — from the Hackney Cyclist account — featured a police officer speaking about LTNs, warning of "a lot of scaremongering" around the schemes...
"[We] wont' be able to help people, we won't be able to catch suspect, there'll be a victim in need and we won't be able to get there because we'll need to do a U-turn... That's just completely false. Please don't believe any scaremongering."
Cycling lawyer at Leigh Day law firm, Rory McCarron, pointed out the response time data from Greenwich showing the biggest cause of delays to London Fire Brigade call outs was traffic, not LTNs. "What you going to do about excessive car use?" he asked.
That was fun. Anyway, as we said at the start, 25 points behind in the polls...
Add new comment
51 comments
You need to be stupid and/or evil to be a rightwinger.
It's worth noting re Susan Hall (#stupiderwithsusan), as I did on Twitter, that "Hazel" is not an emergency services worker, she is a mental health transport assistant, in other words someone who sits in the back of an ordinary, not emergency, transport ambulance and looks after patients with severe MH difficulties. A tremendously worthwhile and praiseworthy job, but one that has absolutely nothing to do with emergency response. Clearly Hall couldn't find a single one of London's 5,700 frontline emergency ambulance staff to appear to support her nonsense on LTNs so had to fall back on someone who works in patient transport. It's also worth noting that the Mayor of London has no control over traffic schemes apart from those on TfL roads, i.e. a small handful of major arterial routes, so her promises to remove LTNs are entirely worthless, it's down to the borough councils. However, she doesn't know what a copper's salary is, how much a bus fare is or who owns Hammersmith Bridge, so I suppose it's a bit much to expect her to know the actual remit of the office for which she is running.
ETA It's worth noting also that her claim that she wants to remove LTNs because she's listening to Londoners and it's what we want is a complete lie, the last poll of which I am aware on the matter (July 2023) found that 58% of Londoners support LTNs with only 17% opposed, hardly a surprising finding for a city in which 50% of households have no access to a motor vehicle.
At least Shaun (Baron Bailey of Paddington...) had some presence and a fairly good backstory. With Susan Hall they seem not even ro be trying...
He blew it when those pictures of his office Xmas party in 2020 surfaced…
(Althought it didn't stop him getting a knighthood).
Didn't they emerge after the election? And he got a peerage!
Fwiw for balance, the current London Mayor and Labour candidate for this year's election stated on his LBC radio show last Thursday in response to a listeners question about LTNs where reportedly one London bus took 121 minutes to travel 2.9miles across Streatham "The LTN in Streatham is causing huge problems" though he also stated Streatham Wells "is a council LTN not my LTN".
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/transport-for-london-lambeth-low-...
Nobody asked the London ambulance service if ambulances were impacted around the Streatham LTN,but I'd be surprised if they weren't given the congestion that it is reportedly causing.
Yes, he has agreed that there are problems with the Streatham LTN and TfL, as an interested party as they are responsible for the A23 which is the road that has primarily suffered from the increased congestion, have been working with the local council to iron out the problems and ensure the scheme can remain in place without having quite such a deleterious impact on surrounding roads. Rather a different approach to Ms Hall's "We must rip them all out" strategy.
the solution to Strethams LTN might well be rip it out, then where would the policy be ?
If we're going to criticise a candidate for election for their stance on LTNs, it's best to get the whole picture from all sides, don't you agree ?
What if *situation I have no proof for* in *area that's not in question* was happening eh?? What then?? Checkmate lefties.
Lol that reminds me of a Zapp Brannigan joke
who cares which side of politics you're on, real world is more complex than "lefties right" or "tories bad", or LTNs always work and you're an idiot to be laughed at if you say otherwise.
Understand that much, and you wont be left using Maslow's hammer as the tool for everything.
Where would what policy be? Khan doesn't have a policy on LTNs because they are not under his control, I don't understand what point you're trying to make. Susan Hall is saying that she wants to "rip out" all LTNs (despite the fact that many of them have been running for decades without anyone making a fuss, and also despite the fact that if she became mayor (which, thank God, is as likely as Lord Lucan winning the next Derby aboard Shergar) she would have no authrity to remove the LTNs whatsoever. Khan has said that he recognises that one LTN may need changes and will work with the local council to effect that. I live relatively close to the Streatham LTN, by the way, and it doesn't need "ripping out", it just needs a few changes. Of course what would make it really good would be if healthy able-bodied people could stop driving 3/4 of a mile to the supermarket, but apparently that is an impossible dream.
Possibly pedantry but surely it's a bit more nuanced - e.g. he presumably can't say "fix this one so" but ... he has been overseeing TfL expanding the cycle ways but been frustrated (indeed - getting a bit chippy with Ken and Chelsey over their intransigence / reversing things after having taken the cash).
If mayors had zero influence over the details the Conservative candidate's pledge to rip these out would be even more risible than it is.
Not being from London it was a long time before I realised the place is basically a bunch of different large towns / small cities stuck together. Who'd want to try to herd those cats?
Northerner here and isn't it just like a Tory to be absolutely full of it 💩. Because they have nothing to actually campaign on without sounding like complete hypocrites.... So back to basic causing hated on the roads wouldn't mind betting this peroxide blonde (can't get any vainer than that type right?) lives in a gated community etc just like how our PMs wife refuses to stay at number 10 because she's have to stop working.... hilarious thing about it is the PM has the gaul to say workers in this country are lazy while profiting from his wife's business cause he has no "real world" quals have you seen the tit handles a hammer? He still doesn't give an F while they keep moving the voting goal posts... He's already referred to moving elections back another two years!
I live in the Forest of Dean (just been for a ride in the glorious spring sunshine) and my MP is Mark Harper, who is attacking the Green Party for raising the price of council owned car parking: because he's got nothing else, quite sad really. https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=800310061908432&set=a.360841945855248
Meanwhile, in other news, locals have taken to calling potholes "Harpers".
meanwhile in the home counties, tory MPs go full on in championing global warming favourable policies, cheaper council car parks looks like small change.
https://www.stevebakerwatch.com/
"global warming policy foundation" is presumably in favour of policies which achieve global warming, as opposed to his involvement in the european research group, which certainly did zero research into Europe whatsoever.
Lowhigh traffic neighbourhoods block ambulances from getting where they need to be.Susan Hall... please don't give this person the oxygen of
publicity. She is not suitable to hold any level of public office, let alone Mayor of London.
She's as truth averse as the previous Tory candidate for the Mayor of London, not to mention the last Tory Mayor of London, the same one who spaffed £42 million of public money up the wall for a useless bridge that nobody wanted and was never built and who then, over-promoted beyond his ability as PM, went on to break the country economically and politically.
C'mon, she is still traumatised from being robbed on the Tube !
And from being taunted by Nick Ferrari
That was mentioned in the Grauniad article I linked to earlier. She went on radio or something saying how London was so awful now and she'd had her bag stolen on the Tube, and the next day someone handed it in because they'd found it abandoned on a platform. Not actually stolen.
Aero helmet, there - is that a time trial?
Pages