Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

feature

How the Elite Square Smart Frame is reinventing indoor cycling at home

We speak to Mattia Gomiero from Elite about the brand's new smart indoor training frame – the Square – and find out how something with four right angles has the potential to revolutionise home training

Elite is known primarily for two things: its fantastic range of accessories – such as its exquisitely manufactured bottle cages and innovative Fly range of water bottles – and its highly rated selection of indoor training options, from the most cutting-edge interactive smart trainers to tried-and-tested rollers.

However, the Italian brand has recently developed something a little different.

The Elite Square is a dedicated frame for home training that looks quite unlike any bike you have ever seen, and which offers functionality quite unlike possibly anything that came before it. 

> Find out more about the Elite Square and where to buy

From its huge range of bike fitting options – the Square can fit riders from 152-198 cm, with seven specific adjustment points, including crank length – to its compatibility with a massive selection of third-party trainers and software, and its ability to replicate any groupset either real or imagined, the Square brings a new level of utility to the indoor training market.

We spoke with Elite’s Mattia Gomiero to find out more about this breakthrough product. 

Elite Square rear detail

road.cc: Let’s start with the biggest question: with so many home training options available, why should people be interested in the Square?

Mattia Gomiero: We have been working on this product for two years. We have put a lot of effort into it, we think that it's a great product and there are a number of different reasons why cyclists should get one. 

The main reason is for cyclists who are tired of removing the back wheel from their own bike when they want to train indoors. Perhaps you store your bike in the garage but your pain cave is on the second floor. You’re fed up of removing the back wheel, carrying the frame upstairs, mounting the frame on the trainer, and then doing all that in reverse when you are finished. It’s a pain.

Or perhaps you share your one trainer with your partner. You both want to do indoor training sessions, but you have to keep removing and replacing each other’s frames depending who is using it. That can become annoying, too. 

But there are also other benefits. For example, in use, the Square is silent. It doesn’t have a cassette, it doesn’t even have a chain. The Square comes with a belt so it is completely quiet, completely clean, more durable and requires less maintenance compared to a bike with a chain.

And finally, you have all the ‘smartness’ offered by Square, with multiple buttons within easy reach of your fingertips on the hoods of the handlebar, offering various functionalities and enhancing your indoor cycling experience.

Some of those issues are solved by buying a smart bike, so why choose the Square?

Smart bikes are fantastic and the price has dropped a lot. But we thought, what about those people who already own a trainer – why should they have to buy a smart bike and sell their old trainer?

Two of the most important features of the Square is that it is what we call ‘App neutral’ and ‘Trainer neutral’. The Elite Square will work with any software and the latest models of almost any trainer that has ANT+ FE-C wireless communication. 

So this is for people who want a stationary bike, who already have a trainer but who don’t want to use their road frame, and who want to access a huge range of functionality without spending thousands of pounds or euros. 

Elite Square front length adjustment

Before we go deeper into its functionality, let’s talk about its appearance. The Square looks almost scientific – it reminds me very much of a bike fitting rig. Why did Elite decide to go with a square design rather than a triangle-based design?

We wanted to do something different and we thought: OK, why does a road bike have the shape it does? It’s to optimise the ride quality, it’s so people can ride faster, it’s the perfect shape for cycling outside. But when training inside, you don’t have to satisfy the same range of criteria.

And, you’re right, there has been a big interest from people who want to do bike fitting with the Square. This was absolutely not the target market we had in mind when we designed it – it was not our chosen final customer and we think the Square will appeal to a far broader range of cyclists – but it could be a product of interest for people involved in bike fitting.

On that note, then, tell us about all the parameters that can be adjusted on the Square?

There are seven areas of adjustment. 

If we start with the most obvious, you can raise and lower the saddle, you can adjust its tilt, and then you can set the saddle position forwards and backwards along a far longer range of movement than normally available using just a saddle’s rails. 

You can then also adjust top tube length and there’s another adjustment point to set handlebar height, and also the handlebar’s fore-aft position. 

Then we have something that is very exciting, which is five different crank length options: 165, 167.5, 170, 172.5 and 175 mm. That is something that seems to have been greatly appreciated by the people who have experienced the Square. 

This works via a cool one-hole ratcheting system that doesn’t require taking off the pedals and putting them back in a different hole in order to have a different length, like in the case of a claw crank solution. This is quick and easy.

Elite Square crank adjustment

I know the handlebar has normal gear shifters but there is also quite a selection of buttons. What can you do with all those?

Some of those buttons have been designed to future-proof the Square although they do offer some functions now, such as controlling our Aria smart fan

But the limit is the sky with these buttons in terms of what can be implemented by our team in the future, together with all the app developers out there, such as Zwift.

The Square’s ability to simulate almost any gearing set-up is also incredible. Tell us about all the groupsets it can imitate?

First of all, there are real shifters. We wanted to reproduce, as far as we could, the real shifting experience of a road bike. While the Square frame might be a creative departure from a traditional triangular frame, on the other side of the coin, we realised that the handlebar and the controls had to be as similar as possible to what people are used to.

We wanted to be able to offer riders an experience that is essentially identical to any groupset available in the real world, meaning we can replicate the entire experience of using a system that’s from Campagnolo, Shimano or SRAM. 

Then we wanted to be able to offer riders the experience of having any amount of chainrings, from single to triple with a choice of 22 to 60 teeth. And we wanted to offer riders the experience of having any cassette from 8 to 13 cogs with 9 to 52 teeth, matching any groupset on the market.

Riders can also set the levers like a sequential gearbox. And the levers can also be used to vary resistance when in stand-alone mode. Meaning you don't have to have a piece of software to be able to train on the Square.

Elite Square handlebar buttons

And selection of gearing set-up is all done through the Elite App?

That’s right. To control all this, you simply download the Elite App and connect it to the Square. From that, you can set any type of groupset that you want or you can modify the set-up to create your own unique gearing options. 

The Square is an incredible piece of kit. How happy are you with the way it has come to market?

We know that cyclists are very demanding, so we know that our products have to be flawless. With the Square, have put a huge amount of research and development to make sure it’s not only the best product that we can make but that it is essentially perfect. Because of that, we think it has the potential to revolutionise many people’s indoor training experience.

To find out more about the Elite Square, visit Elite's website

Add new comment

9 comments

Avatar
Secret_squirrel | 18 min ago
0 likes

This makes no sense, without knowing what the capabilities are needed from the turbo as its just a bike frame with a set of buttons that may or may not be able to connect to anything.

For example the virtual gears have to be implemented by the turbo  - to get that semi-authentic clunk feeling.

How does the belt fit?  Is there a Zwift-esque style Cog to fit on the trainer?

So many questions - what a poorly articulated advertorial - did no-one one explain this to Elite at the proof reading stage?

Sorry Elite - Zwift explained their version much better, its cheaper and it has multi vendor trainer support.

1/10 Must try harder.

 

Avatar
mark1a replied to Secret_squirrel | 2 min ago
0 likes

Secret_squirrel wrote:

This makes no sense, without knowing what the capabilities are needed from the turbo as its just a bike frame with a set of buttons that may or may not be able to connect to anything.

For example the virtual gears have to be implemented by the turbo  - to get that semi-authentic clunk feeling.

How does the belt fit?  Is there a Zwift-esque style Cog to fit on the trainer?

So many questions - what a poorly articulated advertorial - did no-one one explain this to Elite at the proof reading stage?

Sorry Elite - Zwift explained their version much better, its cheaper and it has multi vendor trainer support.

1/10 Must try harder.

This also has multi-trainer support (Elite, Tacx, Wahoo, Magene, Saris are mentioned on their website, otherwise any modern ANT+ FE-C trainer), and tin my option is going to be a better offering than the Zwift Ride because that (understandably) only supports Zwift, whereas this has multi-app support. The bike fit flexibility (including crank lengths) are superior on this too I believe.

https://www.elite-it.com/en/products/home-trainers/ecosystem-accessories...

 

 

Avatar
dlessard75 | 1 hour ago
0 likes

This is a sponsored review right? With all due respect, Wahoo and then Garmin/Tacx revolutionized the segment. Elite followed. Nothing here that you can't get or haven't been able to get for years. 

Avatar
mdavidford replied to dlessard75 | 27 min ago
1 like

dlessard75 wrote:

This is a sponsored review right?

What gave it away? 

 

Avatar
mark1a | 4 hours ago
1 like

Brilliant idea. 

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to mark1a | 2 hours ago
2 likes

mark1a wrote:

Brilliant idea. 

It's a good idea, certainly, but at €1250 (according to DC Rainmaker, odd that this article doesn't mention the price at all) just for the frame without the trainer I can't really see it being in excess of €1000 better than just buying an old bike that fits you for £100 or so – doesn't necessarily even have to be roadworthy, given that you don't really need the brakes or even the wheels – and attaching that permanently to your trainer. Good if two people of very different sizes are sharing the same trainer though, I can see that.

Avatar
Kendalred replied to Rendel Harris | 2 hours ago
1 like

RRP of £1199.99 according to the Elite website, which is probably around €1400.

Avatar
mark1a replied to Rendel Harris | 1 hour ago
2 likes

Rendel Harris wrote:

It's a good idea, certainly, but at €1250 (according to DC Rainmaker, odd that this article doesn't mention the price at all) just for the frame without the trainer I can't really see it being in excess of €1000 better than just buying an old bike that fits you for £100 or so – doesn't necessarily even have to be roadworthy, given that you don't really need the brakes or even the wheels – and attaching that permanently to your trainer. Good if two people of very different sizes are sharing the same trainer though, I can see that.

I got the UK price at £1199 on Elite's website, as you say, not sure why it wasn't in this article.

I was thinking about the bike-fitting options mostly...

I can see a number of LBS, due to online competition, are sensibly looking to pivot away from relying on retail, and move more into servicing and bike-fitting. For a small LBS that wants to do bike fitting, investing in a £10k fit bike rig, or the ££££ needed to become a Retül centre is not a viable option, for less than £2k, they can get one of these with a half-decent turbo and it's a decent solution to build up a fit service.

Also thinking about the £100 old bike option, I personally wouldn't do that as it's another drivetrain to keep going, noisy, messy, etc. A belt drive with virtual gears is much quieter and low maintenance. I like the brand-agnostic element of this, it works with Tacx, Wahoo, Magene, Saris as well as Elite turbo units so easier to upgrade if and when required. If I didn't have a Tacx Neo Bike Smart, I'd be considering this.

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to mark1a | 5 min ago
0 likes

That's actually a great idea and it would be splendid if more bike shops could offer bike fitting. I still have my doubts about how useful it would be for a single home rider or one sharing their trainer with someone relatively close in size. For £1600 (or more, depending on how expensive a trainer one pairs it with) I personally would rather have a Wattbike Proton (adjustable for riders between 4'6" and 6'6") for the aesthetics and portability for those with limited space who want to move a machine around; I assume with the Elite Frame it has to be disconnected from the trainer if you want to move it to a different location.

Latest Comments