Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

news

"I can't think of any British bike race that would run at a profit": Another organiser cancels cycle race amid spiralling costs

Despite praise from locals, the council and police for the inaugural Bourne CiCLE Festival, Brian Moran has pulled the plug on future editions due to "red tape and police costs"...

The organiser of the National A-level Bourne CiCLE Festival race has cancelled the event, which was supposed to be reappearing on the calendar for the first time since its inaugural edition in 2019, citing spiralling police costs and bureaucracy for its cancellation.

Brian Moran's event, part of the wider Bourne Festival of Wheels first held in the Lincolnshire market town in September 2019, will not be returning this year, the organiser being forced to pull the plug when informed that police costs for motorbike outriders to marshal the race would cost £35,000, ten times the £3,500 cost five years earlier, that despite the 2024 route being "simpler". 

This was due to Lincolnshire Police, who provided support for the race in 2019, no longer being able to provide escort cover for the race, meaning the Central Escort Group was called on instead. However, for the CiCLE Festival race to go ahead, the police wanted 30 police motorbikes and command cars involved, a similar level of policing as to what is used for the Tour of Britain or past RideLondon events.

"There were a few complications with bureaucracy which delayed things, but 
I had my first meeting with the police in November," Mr Moran explained. "There was a degree of dismissal about what we could do. 

"Duncan Street [liaison to British Cycling and Central Escort Group] was brought into it and said he would do a recon of the route. I offered to accompany him as I live on the course, and the next thing I heard was a letter from him on the 1st of December saying he did the course inspection, and that he thinks that for the route that we've chosen, we need 30 police bikes... that's going to cost £35,000.

"He completely ignored the fact that in 2019, we ran six bikes that cost £3,500 for two days, that was irrelevant."

Negotiations eventually saw the number of motorbikes required reduced to ten, cutting costs to around £13,000, but this expenditure was still more than three times greater than it had been in 2019 and impossible for Moran to fund.

"Why it worked okay in 2019, and a simpler route in 2024 was going to be such a problem? That I always struggled to get my head around," Moran told road.cc, explaining that even with the police motorbikes reduced to ten, four more than were used in 2019, it "was still going to be too much money for what we budgeted".

> "Unfortunately you can't control every idiot on the road": Road race organiser frustrated as cyclists almost hit by "inconsiderate" Uber driver

"I spent the next two weeks thinking, I'm now three months behind in the planning for this, and I can't fulfil all the promises I made to the funding people to deliver what I promised. The only thing I can do is cancel it."

The race, part of a town-wide Bourne Festival of Wheels, was to be funded with help from South Kesteven's allocation of the Shared Prosperity Fund, and would have seen a men's and women's race use a circuit out of the town, alongside skateboard, BMX, rollerblade, and other events over the weekend.

Much of Moran's frustration comes from the success of the 2019 event, which earned praise from competitors, the council, police, fire service and other local stakeholders.

"I can't understand why one year was so simple and we were congratulated, and a few years later on a simple course, we're having these problems," he said. 

"I wouldn't organise a race nowadays that didn't have a police escort and wasn't of a certain stature, but the cost of running a bike race, you've got to pay for accredited marshals nowadays, you've got to pay for police bikes. There are lots of costs involved in all that sort of stuff.

"I can't think of any bike race that would run at a profit."

> "Continuing as we are remains unsafe": Calls for British Cycling action as rider airlifted to hospital after collision with stationary car during race

Looking at the existential issues many races in Britain at all levels face currently, Moran questions where races can bring money in, suggesting that "very few events would actually appeal to a sponsor or TV company".

"Go to the average bike race, and it is two men and a dog at the finish. They don't finish in the middle of a town, because that costs money."

In January, British Cycling's elite road racing task force, led by Ed Clancy, shared recommendations for "reinvigorating" the flagging domestic scene.

2023 Women's Ryedale Grasscrete Grand Prix (Craig Zadoroznyj/SWpix.com)

The task force engaged with more than 250 people across the sport to consider the composition of the elite national calendar, the challenges facing the rapidly dwindling number of domestic teams, and opportunities to grow the reach and profile of local races.

Its 16 recommendations to the governing body – which aim to help create a varied, competitive, and sustainable National Road Series, a National Circuit Series tailored for mass audiences, and ensure that Britain retains its WorldTour stage races following the recent demise of Tour of Britain and Women's Tour organisers SweetSpot – can be read in full here.

British Cycling has since committed to trying to put on the Tour of Britain and a women's equivalent in 2024, races plunged into uncertainty by organiser and promoter SweetSpot entering liquidation.

Dan is the road.cc news editor and joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan has been at road.cc for four years and mainly writes news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He has hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.

Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, when he's not working you'll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he'll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he's a bit strange like that.

Add new comment

16 comments

Avatar
eddiecurrent2000 | 3 months ago
1 like

I think the problem has been made worse by British Cycling's decision to follow a different path to that of Welsh Cycling.
In Wales we have a core group of CSAS accredited marshalls (Community Safety Accreditation Scheme), which is run by Gwent Police on behalf of the Welsh police forces. This scheme gives the accredited marshalls a very narrow band of powers which are actually legal powers to stop and direct traffic or direct pedestrians . This gives the Welsh cycling scene a degree of autonomy from the Welsh police forces, whilst still maintaining the safety that a police outrider or stationary officer would provide.

It give both static marshalls, AND motorcycle marshalls the powers. Therefore we rarely engage the services of a police escort unless it is one of the more prestigious races. Our motorcycle marshalls are key to stopping traffic on the route and gives the races a degree of safety which I don't believe the police escort necessarily would, simply because the police aren't used to the dynamics in a road race.

CSAS isn't perfect, we still get drive arounds, but those can carry legal penalties which the BC model doesn't have. Our marshalls are well trained and experienced and have transformed the Welsh race scene. Obviously we are still in close contact with any police force we race in, and we get approval from them in most cases, and the scheme has been broadly welcomed by the forces as it gives them fewer headaches and staffing issues, plus less red tape. I think if BC had similar talks with the Police forces in England, and took the Welsh example with them, you would find that costs of races where police outriders were once needed will come down.

Avatar
Jimmy Ray Will | 8 months ago
1 like

I keep saying the same thing with this subject... the focus needs to be moved from the pinnacle / elite end of the sport, and instead centred around providing viable sport for the majority.

Get more people racing, crucially, keep more people racing and so many of these problems will sort themselves out. 

Things I personally believe BC should be doing centrally to support the sport include;

- using what muscle it has to identify and secure use of suitable closed road circuits. By that I mean airfields, race courses, private estates

- revamping points allocations / licence categories / race structures. Currently there are 2 categories for ~80% of riders, and then 3 categories to separate the remaining 20%. This provides compromised racing for the vast majority of racers. 

- revisiting the language used around, and the conscious / unconsious devaluing of circuit races - over road races - as again, the vast majority of competitive racers will spend most of their time circuit racing, and not road racing. 

- update the website, its a blocker rather than enabler for cycle sport in its current guise.

Appeal to the masses, and the masses will engage. Greater engagement creates greater opportunities for all levels of racing. 

Avatar
Cugel | 8 months ago
3 likes

Now a decade or three ago, I used to road race in many club events around Northern England. It was relatively easy to organise such events then; less bureaucracy (although not free of it) but also back roads - and even town centre Sunday roads - that were extremely low-traffic, with some (such as for town centre Sunday crits) so low-traffic that it allowed road closures for a couple of hours or so.

But even then, there were traffic incidents, even when the routes were well-marshalled and the riders very considerate and adherent to the rules for such racing in traffic. It was inevitable, given the nature of racing and the nature of some loon drivers.

These days, the racers often seem less disciplined, as club etiqutte and behaviours seem more me-my-I these days. In addition, traffic is heavier and the general standard of driving more aggresive in many places. Add the now large costs and additional bureaucracy and its easy to see why road racing on open roads has become untenable.

There is an obvious solution, which is to build dedicated cycle racing circuits. When I raced there was (and still is) a good crit circuit on the riverside in North Lancaster. The whole area is closed to traffic but is part of a wider sports facility that also has car parking and changing facilities. There's a good case for including such dedicated cycle racing facilities in any newly proposed sports faciity - built from scratch or as part of an upgrade to existing sports facilities, if land is available.

Yes, I know - not a big priority in today's broken and bust Britain. Yet it looks like the only option. And, after all, no one would propose a car racing event on open roads, would they?   1

Avatar
DavidLeslie replied to Cugel | 8 months ago
3 likes

I currently coach and (badly) race on that Salt Ayre circuit in Lancaster. I'm down there about 4 times per week. It was initially installed before the sports centre, by a group of local cycling clubs. The volunteers do their best to look after it, but it's a constant struggle, with trees and other growth affecting the tarmac. Most importantly there is no protective fencing, and in the last year we've had incursions from horses and carts, and kids in balaclavas on motorbikes, as well as the usual dog-walkers, not realising or not caring that it's a dedicated and paid-for cycling facility. British Cycling do their best to help us to keep it up to scratch, but it's really not a council priority.

The really good examples of specialist circuits are more recent, and are all fully fenced off. Tameside, Carlisle, Colne, Litherland, Rhyl, Linlithgow, Lochgelly, Wyke all just about within day trip distance of Lancaster. There's a brilliant youth racing scene on these circuits (including Salt Ayre), and for someone as bad at racing as I am they're fine. But for competent adult racers the circuits are very short and twisty - only about 1km - and it's a completely different dynamic to an open road race. It really isn't the whole solution.

Avatar
Backladder replied to DavidLeslie | 8 months ago
0 likes

Back when I raced in the Manchester area we regularly raced on the three sisters karting circuit near wigan, is that still in use?

Avatar
DavidLeslie replied to Backladder | 8 months ago
0 likes

I've not come across that one. Sorry.

Avatar
Backladder replied to DavidLeslie | 8 months ago
0 likes
Avatar
Drinfinity replied to Backladder | 8 months ago
0 likes

Yes, there are events there, although not so much racing. 
https://www.wigan.gov.uk/BeWell/Activities-sports/Cycle-Three-Sisters.aspx

Avatar
john_smith replied to Cugel | 8 months ago
0 likes

Quite a few clubs in the Netherlands have their own circuits. They don't look like a lot of fun to me, but given that most roads are closed to cyclists (at least in the Randstad region) and many of the cycle paths aren't a lot better than the ones in the UK, I guess they don't feel they have much choice.

Avatar
chrisonabike replied to john_smith | 8 months ago
1 like
john_smith wrote:

...[in NL] many of the cycle paths aren't a lot better than the ones in the UK ...

I hope you can back that up!

That's fighting talk!  The UK proudly has both some pinnacles of world-beating (and bike-beating) dangerous / totally baffling crap infra AND a very low average quality of cycle infra.  (We normally favour a devastating combination of narrow / poorly-marked / "shared use" / not protected from motor vehicles / disconnected and of course "stops just before every junction, where it is most needed").

By contrast while NL has some low points (ha!) in its cycle infra* [various examples] [in Amsterdam] [more general points] (and they do have cycle lanes also) it's ubiquitous, fairly standard, mostly of pretty good quality [examples] AND still being improved with regular "highlights".

* Not surprising given it's everywhere in the country and has been being installed for decades now.

Avatar
KDee replied to chrisonabike | 8 months ago
3 likes

Yeah...we have terrible infra in NL, like this absolute horror through the dunes between Wassenaar and Katwijk  😂

Avatar
john_smith replied to KDee | 8 months ago
0 likes

Nice dunes, but you've got to get there first. And we're talking about racing here, not pottering around on an omafiets.

Avatar
KDee replied to john_smith | 8 months ago
2 likes

I'm not pottering about on an omafiets. And getting there is a thousand times better than attempting the same in the UK. I'd say for me to get there, of the 10km maybe 0.5km is in a murderstrip, the rest on protected infra. 

Avatar
chrisonabike replied to john_smith | 8 months ago
0 likes

Ah - you may be interested in this one:

https://www.aviewfromthecyclepath.com/2008/09/speed.html

However I'd completely agree if you mean "NL infra isn't designed for cycle racing". That's true - in the same way an A-road / dual carriageway isn't.

You *could* race on either, assuming they were empty, but there are different issues using each for other purposes than its design. That's a high capacity for fast motor traffic for roads, safe and convenient cycling with high *average* speed through avoiding complete stops (> 12mph+ I'd guess) for Dutch cycling infra.

So yes - the fit and the brave ("1% ers"?) DO stand to lose some "accidental benefits" - but if they're really independent-minded perhaps that won't stop them?

Avatar
Paul J replied to john_smith | 8 months ago
0 likes
john_smith wrote:

They don't look like a lot of fun to me, but given that most roads are closed to cyclists (at least in the Randstad region) and many of the cycle paths aren't a lot better than the ones in the UK, I guess they don't feel they have much choice.

There seems to be a fairly decent racing scene in the Netherlands. It seems to be a lot healthier than in the UK anyway. There are usually a good few sections of wider cycle paths and rural roads that are suitable for racing. The Norcal Cycling channel has a couple of videos from the dutch national scene (with some WT pros featuring now and then, for training).

It might be true most roads are closed to cycling, but there are always some roads open to cyclists somewhere nearby. Rural access roads e.g..

Ireland, thankfully, still seems to have a reasonable amateur road racing scene. Inc. down to small ones run by clubs. Not as bogged down by bureaucracy here - and not as densely populated as most of UK (bar Scotland) I guess.

Avatar
Freddy56 | 8 months ago
2 likes

Fair play for the effort. Shame of red tape will kill of local road racing

Latest Comments