Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

"A bike lane doesn't close a village": Dame Sarah Storey defends cycle lane blamed for "ruining business" and "killing village", calls shops closing "a coincidence, not an unexpected consequence"

Traders say scheme has hit business and left "nowhere to park", even though the project saw 80 new off-road spaces created, Greater Manchester's Active Travel Commissioner instead pointing to the cost of living crisis and impact of the pandemic...

Britain's most successful Paralympian, Dame Sarah Storey, who balances training with her role as Greater Manchester's Active Travel Commissioner, has defended a cycle lane project in the area, arguing concerns it has "killed" business are unfounded.

Business owners in the Rochdale village of Castleton have spoken out about the bike lane project, part of a wider £4.4 million road improvements scheme. Back in March, we reported that traders had claimed sales are down 50 per cent and the area had been "killed" by the cycle lane leaving "nowhere to park", that despite the project seeing the creation of 80 new off-street spaces.

Now, phoning into a Radio Manchester show featuring Mayor Andy Burnham and the Active Travel Commissioner, a concerned resident said the cycle lane's construction had "closed off the road for two years", caused "chaos" and was "ruining business".

"When it was being built it was just chaos. [And since it was completed] I've seen two people on that bike lane since it's been there and you were one of them," the caller called Gary said in an interview reported by the Manchester Evening News.

In reply, Dame Sarah Storey argued "a bike lane doesn't close a village" and pointed to other economic factors that have hit people across the country in recent times.

She said: "It's a coincidence, not an unexpected consequence. The timing in Castleton was really challenging, with the cost of living crisis and coming out of the pandemic. When you've two things like that colliding, they've had to take it to experts to discuss how they can sort the economic side out.

"A bike lane doesn't close a village. It opens it up and enables more people to choose to move. Not everybody can drive, not everybody owns a car and they're now connected to a train station and soon to the town centre through the extension."

Burnham followed up by adding that while he appreciates it "may not be being used at the level that we would like, that will come over time".

"If there is a detriment to the high street, this will more than bring it back. In time, [Castleton] will become a really attractive place — it already is, but it will become even better."

In March, business owners blamed the cycle lane for their struggles, the owner of a local chippy saying customers used to "pull up, order the food, get back into the car, and away they go".

"It's supposed to get better but I can't see it, to be honest," Mark Foster of the New Bridge chip shop said, suggesting trade had decreased by a "drastic" 50 per cent. Likewise, the owner of the Mini Market vape shop, said half their business had "gone" as "if they can't park outside, they can't stop here".

"If it keeps going like this all of us will have to close down," Rahand Mahmud said. The BBC also heard from residents who called it a "total waste of money" and claimed that the project has "killed" the village.

Dan is the road.cc news editor and joined in 2020 having previously written about nearly every other sport under the sun for the Express, and the weird and wonderful world of non-league football for The Non-League Paper. Dan has been at road.cc for four years and mainly writes news and tech articles as well as the occasional feature. He has hopefully kept you entertained on the live blog too.

Never fast enough to take things on the bike too seriously, when he's not working you'll find him exploring the south of England by two wheels at a leisurely weekend pace, or enjoying his favourite Scottish roads when visiting family. Sometimes he'll even load up the bags and ride up the whole way, he's a bit strange like that.

Add new comment

31 comments

Avatar
FionaJJ replied to E6toSE3 | 1 month ago
1 like

It's such short-term thinking. Rather than trying to tackle the actual root causes of crime, tinker around with things that give the pretence of safety, but make life worse for all of us.

There are parallel issues with the free bus passes for kids in Scotland. There have been some inevitable teething problems, but putting them aside, there is now a trend for local Facebook pages to blame any kind of minor disturbance, or gatherings involving young people who might possibly get up to no good, on the free bus passes. You see, free bus passes allow children from the poorer parts of the city go to nice places, where previously all teens from those areas had responsible parents and spent their free time helping old ladies cross the road.

The idea that making our public spaces nicer and more accessible isn't just a nice thing to have, but will improve the lives of people who will be more likely to want to stay engaged in society is beyond a lot of keyboard warriers.

Pages

Latest Comments