Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Picking riders in the break after the race had started sue to clocks going forwards

Discuss. I for one, think that is taking the piss.

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

73 comments

Avatar
enrique replied to northstar | 10 years ago
0 likes
northstar wrote:

It's not a loophole and any points gained this way should be removed.

Sure, but let's make sure the community stays together. I don't want Wiggy to leave, not this way, at least.  39 Hmmm... does he mean he's leaving the forum or the game?...  39

Avatar
Wig_Billy | 10 years ago
0 likes

My position.

This is a competitive game and I try to do as well as possible in it. I always compare the deadline times with the race start times because I know from experience that mistakes happen. I do this to give myself an advantage and I'm unapologetic about that. There is no rule that all transfers have to be made before a race starts, so to call it cheating is ridiculous.

When I started playing this game it was just for fun, but these days I play to win. Unfortunately it seems this attitude is incompatible with the forum, so I think it's probably time to say goodbye.

I enjoyed my time here. Farewell road.cc forum.  103

Avatar
backflipbedlem replied to Wig_Billy | 10 years ago
0 likes
Wig_Billy wrote:

My position.

This is a competitive game and I try to do as well as possible in it. I always compare the deadline times with the race start times because I know from experience that mistakes happen. I do this to give myself an advantage and I'm unapologetic about that. There is no rule that all transfers have to be made before a race starts, so to call it cheating is ridiculous.

When I started playing this game it was just for fun, but these days I play to win. Unfortunately it seems this attitude is incompatible with the forum, so I think it's probably time to say goodbye.

I enjoyed my time here. Farewell road.cc forum.  103

Don't go Wig_Billy you're my inspiration! I want to win too!!!
But still have fun at the same time!!

I think in the morning everyone will have calmed down and we can all have a weeks break ready to come back and fight it out again over the Women!!

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to Wig_Billy | 10 years ago
0 likes
Wig_Billy wrote:

My position.

This is a competitive game and I try to do as well as possible in it. I always compare the deadline times with the race start times because I know from experience that mistakes happen. I do this to give myself an advantage and I'm unapologetic about that. There is no rule that all transfers have to be made before a race starts, so to call it cheating is ridiculous.

When I started playing this game it was just for fun, but these days I play to win. Unfortunately it seems this attitude is incompatible with the forum, so I think it's probably time to say goodbye.

I enjoyed my time here. Farewell road.cc forum.  103

I have pretty much come to the same conclusion. I'm sick of bitching and moaning about this, that and the other.

I don't get paid to run the game (nor have I ever asking to be paid), I do it because I used to enjoy it and thought I was helping for the greater good of others. Lately it is just taking up time that I could be doing better things with and its the same people day in day out moaning about something.

I now have a business to run, so my time is money. I can ill afford to be sat on here doing rosters, sorting stages, points, finding startlists. Checking them every day before a race to make sure they are as correct as I can make them.

Emailing, tweeting and phoning race organisers to see if I can get information about races....etc

Avatar
enrique replied to Wig_Billy | 10 years ago
0 likes
Wig_Billy wrote:

When I started playing this game it was just for fun, but these days I play to win.

Stay. There's a lot of people here that admire your play and competitive spirit.

Wig_Billy wrote:

There is no rule that all transfers have to be made before a race starts, so to call it cheating is ridiculous.

You're right. But leaving over this is ridiculous, too. No one's asking you to leave.

Wig_Billy wrote:

I do this to give myself an advantage and I'm unapologetic about that... it seems this attitude is incompatible with the forum...

No it isn't. Many of us think this is peanuts... Stay!  1

Avatar
enrique | 10 years ago
0 likes
Joelsim wrote:

Just click on his name and see that he added 2 of the breakaway riders after the race had started.

That's pretty cool. Well, Wig Billy has always seemed like a decent person here on the forum. I'm sure he didn't mean to cheat per se. He just noticed a loophole and used it to his advantage. If he did do it deliberately, well, of course, that's not right. But, at any rate, let him give his version of the events.

I just don't know if Dave and company should become detectives and pursue this like it was a major crime. I think it's bad enough to be 'outed' here. I'm pretty sure they won't doing that (!) again (!). Not after this (!) Look at how rabidly G defends himself. It wasn't right, but, what to do now? I agree with Twy:

Twybaydos wrote:

... chalk it up to experience... and... ensure it doesn't happen again next year

And I wonder if they come down hard on these people, well, crap, doesn't it take away from the 'camraderie' here?  7

They're 'outed' already. Now what? I guess let them address the issue and wait to see what Dave thinks...

Avatar
Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes

Wig_Billy hasn't "made a killing" he's gained about 20 points.

Also, what are you saying about Wig and Gilbert? Call me Maybe?

Not of that makes sense

Avatar
Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes

Veelers Wheel
Queens Park Riders
Call me maybe?

That's just a cursory look at the top few on this stage.

Avatar
Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes

It cannot be done, not can individual penalties

Avatar
northstar replied to Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes
Gkam84 wrote:

It cannot be done, not can individual penalties

Maybe it can't, either way, something has to be done.

Avatar
simon F | 10 years ago
0 likes

What a load of bollocks. It's just a game. If a few people got a small advantage in a competition that lasts for months, really who cares. Some people will have made legitimate transfers close to the deadline - how will you separate them out from your revenge? What's the prize - a pair of sunglasses. Not really worth this amount of arguing, especially if whoever wins them didn't make any disputed transfers

Meanwhile, and more importantly, when are we going to get the Volta Catalunya final scores - I really want to know how far I fell in the FS league.

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to simon F | 10 years ago
0 likes
simon F wrote:

Meanwhile, and more importantly, when are we going to get the Volta Catalunya final scores - I really want to know how far I fell in the FS league.

I think TER is on the scores for this, I can go do them now though.

Actually, I think someone is already on them

Avatar
Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes

Wig_Billy has made a killing.

Luckily most that I have looked at don't seem to have noticed. It's not difficult to see those that have.

Avatar
northstar | 10 years ago
0 likes

Ok, all transfers involving riders who were in the break after the ride/race started removed? (if that can be done of course)

Avatar
livestrongnick | 10 years ago
0 likes

Huge can of worms all over the spring classics today!  7

Avatar
northstar | 10 years ago
0 likes

The posted transfer deadline was available to all way before, reset them to this, problem solved.

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to northstar | 10 years ago
0 likes
northstar wrote:

The posted transfer deadline was available to all way before, reset them to this, problem solved.

The problem is, the deadline didn't change at all. The clocks did. So a roll back, won't work

Avatar
enrique replied to Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes
Gkam84 wrote:

... a roll back, won't work

Why don't you assign yourself a 50 point penalty or have Dave do it?  1

Avatar
Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes

No-one gaining an advantage in the top 10. How do I know.

Go here, click on the team name and you can see all the transfers

http://fantasy.road.cc/leagues?action=show&lid=0&rgid=0&sid=7507&ldtid=3...

There are three solutions to this.

Dave might be able to do a roll back, which is fine for me, because I will actually score more points.

The race can be void and everyone can have 0 points

It can be left as it.

There is nothing in the game for giving individual teams 0 points while leaving others alone.

Avatar
drheaton | 10 years ago
0 likes

Some of the ideas being bandied around are sadly unrealistic. There are some people who will have legitimately made transfers after the race started without realising or without seeking to gain advantage and to reset everyone to their teams at the point the race started would unfairly affect them.

Likewise there may also be someone who honestly brought in one of the break after the race started without knowing it. It would not be fair to penalise them but its also impossible to weed those people out from those who made transfers to gain an advantage.

Sadly I don't think that there are any ways to sort this out without affecting people who genuinely made transfers without trying to gain advantage.

Avatar
chiv30 replied to drheaton | 10 years ago
0 likes
drheaton wrote:

Some of the ideas being bandied around are sadly unrealistic. There are some people who will have legitimately made transfers after the race started without realising or without seeking to gain advantage and to reset everyone to their teams at the point the race started would unfairly affect them.

Likewise there may also be someone who honestly brought in one of the break after the race started without knowing it. It would not be fair to penalise them but its also impossible to weed those people out from those who made transfers to gain an advantage.

Sadly I don't think that there are any ways to sort this out without affecting people who genuinely made transfers without trying to gain advantage.

I'n all fairness everyone knew when the "official" deadline was as we had been counting it down for at least 24 hrs , Anyone who made a transfer after that should be re scored based on the team at the official race start irrelevant if they realised or not ,tbh most people who would have changed their team would have been aware of what they were doing imo

Avatar
Joelsim replied to | 10 years ago
0 likes
chiv30 wrote:
drheaton wrote:

Some of the ideas being bandied around are sadly unrealistic. There are some people who will have legitimately made transfers after the race started without realising or without seeking to gain advantage and to reset everyone to their teams at the point the race started would unfairly affect them.

Likewise there may also be someone who honestly brought in one of the break after the race started without knowing it. It would not be fair to penalise them but its also impossible to weed those people out from those who made transfers to gain an advantage.

Sadly I don't think that there are any ways to sort this out without affecting people who genuinely made transfers without trying to gain advantage.

I'n all fairness everyone knew when the "official" deadline was as we had been counting it down for at least 24 hrs , Anyone who made a transfer after that should be re scored based on the team at the official race start irrelevant if they realised or not ,tbh most people who would have changed their team would have been aware of what they were doing imo

It's not difficult to see those who have done it just by looking at the transfers.

Avatar
Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes

All are stuck. Updating.

Just cleared my cache and that hasn't helped either.

Avatar
Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes

I have been getting a 'Please wait, we are updating the game' for a couple of hours now. And your link does the same thing. Both on my PC and my phone.

Avatar
Gkam84 replied to Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes
Joelsim wrote:

I have been getting a 'Please wait, we are updating the game' for a couple of hours now. And your link does the same thing. Both on my PC and my phone.

Just running the update again, I think it may have jammed up

Avatar
Gkam84 | 10 years ago
0 likes
Avatar
chiv30 replied to | 10 years ago
0 likes
Gkam84 wrote:

What is stuck? http://fantasy.road.cc/rules and here http://fantasy.road.cc/howto

For the record I'm getting the currently updating msg as well both from your link and my own bookmark

Avatar
Joelsim | 10 years ago
0 likes

Wonder what the competition rules mention about the race deadlines?

I would look but it appears to be stuck, obviously knows there's been cheating happening.

Avatar
ajmarshal1 | 10 years ago
0 likes

Ah, the old 'exploiting a loophole available to everyone' excuse.

Cheating. This is why I didn't bother this season.

Avatar
Joelsim replied to | 10 years ago
0 likes
ajmarshal1 wrote:

Ah, the old 'exploiting a loophole available to everyone' excuse.

Cheating. This is why I didn't bother this season.

Yep.

Leaves a really sour taste. We may as well get Lance involved.

Pages

Latest Comments