Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Custom Ti: Wittson vs Spin

Haven't used the open forum before, so be gentle.......

Am weighing up a custom Ti frameset for a disc brake roady with enough room for some chunkier tyres (up to 32, for potential Tour of Flanders/Paris Roubaix action - I cycled in Belgium earlier this year and my fillings were nearly shaken out of my mouth).

Have looked at stock bikes such as Kinesis, Sabbath and Enigma from the UK and then the SUPER premium Moots and Seven from the US. However, I think I'm going to go custom, as prices can actually be cheaper than compared to some of the stock bikes and I'm always one for supporting the underdog, provided the quality and workmanship is there.

Have spoken to both framebuilders and they have come up with similar price points: http://wittson.com/ and http://ridefullgas.com/lightning/ (both builders will do custom geometry, allow fixings for disc mounts, rack mounts and mudguard eyes as well).

Any thoughts/recommendations much appreciated......If there's any makers I have missed (I know of Mosaic custom frames, but don't have the money to throw at a Passoni, Comtat or Legend)

If you're new please join in and if you have questions pop them below and the forum regulars will answer as best we can.

Add new comment

13 comments

Avatar
graybags | 9 years ago
0 likes

HI,

I've pushed the button on an order from Cielo Rosso, Neil sounds like he knows what he's talking about and is really helpful, any further feedback on your bike, is all good ?

Avatar
monty dog | 10 years ago
0 likes

There are a number of these brands listed who buy their frames from the same factories in Xiamen, China. Frame prices are from $600 direct for a single frame.

Only Enigma actually make ti frames in the UK, but their stock frames are oriental though.

I've bought 6 custom ti frames direct from China - 4 from XACD and the last 2 from Waltly titanium. I prefer the latter - better quality and more reasonable to deal with. XACD are a pain in the ar$e and more pricey in comparison. My latest frame, a fat-bike for 5" tyres arrived last week  4

Worth looking at www.spanner.org.uk for more experiences/inspiration - one of mines on there too.

Avatar
Simmo72 | 10 years ago
0 likes

+1 for Ceilo Rosso. Love mine. Same high standard as the big guns.

Avatar
pcaley | 10 years ago
0 likes

If you really know what you want and can recognise it on a drawing you could always go direct to the factory in China.
xacd.com.cn

Avatar
notfastenough | 10 years ago
0 likes

Cielo Rosso? Full custom Ti from a British brand (obviously made in the far east though) for £700 has to be worth a look.

http://cielorossobikes.com/cielo-rosso-custom-built-titanium-frames-601-...

Avatar
tomisitt | 10 years ago
0 likes

The Spin is certainly good for fast/hard riding. I'm 86kg, so no lightweight, but even so the pavé wasn't too bad. I tried 28mm Conti 4 Seasons on the Spitfire — fine at the back, fractionally too big at the front with the standard Spin fork. Might try 27mm Open Paves to see how they work.

PBP? You must be mad!

Avatar
Rod Marton | 10 years ago
0 likes

A couple of other suggestions for custom titanium: Qoroz, Burls and Triton. I've seen examples of all of these and reports are good, however I've never ridden titanium and can't pass any comment from personal experience.

Avatar
tomisitt | 10 years ago
0 likes

You really don't need 32mm tyres for cobbles, do you?. This year I rode the last 110km of the Roubaix route (45km of cobbles) and all the major climbs of the Ronde on my Spitfire MkIII with 25mm Conti 4 Seasons running on Archetype rims. Not exactly smooth, but perfectly acceptable on some pretty tough surfaces.

Agree with Pierre that it's a great bike, beautifully built, and the company is great to deal with. Not sure I'd put a rack or mudguards on something like a Lightning, but each to their own.

Avatar
only1redders replied to tomisitt | 10 years ago
0 likes

I tend to agree on racks/mudguards. The bike is being built for fast/hard riding (although I'm no racer), but also considering endurance events, such as PBP (1200km in 90 hours will require something fast, but also comfortable!).

I'm a high 80/low 90kg power rider, so I really wouldn't float over cobbles. Need as much air in those tyres as possible, so I reckon I'll be using at least 25mm on a wider rim, or possibly 28s.

Avatar
Gasman Jim | 10 years ago
0 likes

Lynskey Sportive Disc?
I've had mine for about 18 months now and it's a great wet weather / winter / rough roads bike.

Avatar
Pierre | 10 years ago
0 likes

(it's probably worth only posting a question once... : )

I can't speak for Wittson; I've got a Spin and it's excellent. The quality of the workmanship and attention to detail is superb and it's a fantastic bike to ride, even nicer than my previous Litespeed Archon Ti. I've built up quite a few wheels with Spin's hubs too and they're a great company to deal with, very friendly and helpful.

HTH!

Avatar
only1redders replied to Pierre | 10 years ago
0 likes

Whoops, sorry, got confused with Save/Preview. Over zealous!!!

Interesting that you mention Archon Ti - that's the bike I had that rattled me to pieces. Have you got the Spitfite? I have spoken to Drew and he's proposed an altered Lightning to accommodate what I want.

Any comments on the Spin rims? I've seen mostly positive stuff previously, apart from the 1 star review in 2012, which apparently was partly down to some duff bearings.

Avatar
Pierre replied to only1redders | 10 years ago
0 likes
only1redders wrote:

Have you got the Spitfite? I have spoken to Drew and he's proposed an altered Lightning to accommodate what I want.

Any comments on the Spin rims? I've seen mostly positive stuff previously, apart from the 1 star review in 2012, which apparently was partly down to some duff bearings.

Yes, mine's a Spitfire and I love it; I've only test-ridden a Lightning but it felt like the Spitfire but slightly race-ier. That said, if Drew's going to draw up custom geometry he can tune it to however you'd like it.

I've ridden on three generations of Spin carbon rims and they improve each time round. The K2 R50 24mm clincher rims are just superb, I have them with 23mm Schwalbe One tyres on and they feel like riding tubulars, very fast, very smooth and nicely aero. I've got a pair of the 23mm alloy rims and they feel similar to Velocity A23s (although they're slightly heavier, but the build quality is better). As far as I know there was a problem with a previous generation of hubs where the bearing seats weren't especially durable but the new F50(?) and R50 hubs don't have that problem - they've been great!

Latest Comments