Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Bad ad update 2: It's all about the code

Another breakthrough in our war against irritating and annoying ads on road.cc

As you’ve probably gathered by now we’re on a mission to make your road.cc experience as pleasant as possible when it comes to the ads served on the site. 

Annoying ads have never been a massive problem on the site, but they have been a persistent one - particularly for those of you using the site via a mobile phone. 

In my last update I told you about some of the measures we’ve taken to try and eliminate these ads from the site - most notably: 

With your help those measures have gone a long way to dramatically cutting the number of irritating ads that get through our defences. 

Now we’ve added another weapon - a visible bit of code on every ad we serve that isn’t ours. You might have noticed it over the last few days, Or you might not: it’s designed to be fairly unobtrusive until you need it. 

Each ad has its own unique identifier code and our ad network can use that code to block an annoying ad at source. Basically it’s the same bit of code you’d send us if you followed the steps suggested in our bad ad reporting page to ‘inspect element’, but just sticking it on the ad itself makes things a whole lot simpler for you when you come to report it, just take a screen grab and upload it to the bad ad page, you could even just tell us the code on there and it’d work too. 

This also removes one of the problems some people have had trying to get the ad ID because their browsers don’t allow them to inspect the ad code or indeed any code - yes we’re looking at you Safari, and IoS. The latter being a particular pain because there seem to be phases where iPhones seem to be particularly prone to being served dodgy ads. 

This should make the whole process of reporting annoying or irritating ads a lot easier - so take a bow Big Dave, our back end tinkerer in chief for coming up with the idea. 

 

What we class as an annoying ad and how to help us stop them?

  • Any ad that attempts to hijack or take over the main part of the screen
  • Any auto-play video ad - especially looped ones you can’t turn off
  • Any ad that attempts to auto-scroll your browser down the page - we REALLY hate those, but not as much as
  • Any ad that redirects your browser to the app store or to another website - usually a redirect to a betting app or site.

The latter two are the most insidious types of annoying ad we have to deal with, luckily they are rare - though many sites have similar problems with them.

So how can you help? Well with our Annoying and intrusive ad reporting page you can help us captures as much information about these ads as possible – screen grabs of the offending advert with the ad code would be a massive help. If you want to go old skool you can pull the ad code out of the ad itself; we’ve even got a handy video showing you how to get the code,  basically it involves right clicking on the ad, selecting 'Inspect element' and copying the highlighted code. It would also be useful if you could tell us the time zone you were in when you saw the ad and the time of day.

That code gives the ad network - who also want to deal with the problem – the necessary information to track down and block the sources of the offending ads.

Because of the way they work auto redirects are harder to deal with – a piece of code, which might be time limited, is injected into a seemingly innocuous ad which as it loads then deploys the redirect. The problem here being that because the redirect occurs before the page has loaded it’s hard/impossible to know which ad caused the problem. Even so, if you do find this happening to you it’s still worth you giving any information you can about what happened – obviously if by any chance the page did load before it redirected we’d love to know what was on it, but we’d also like to know where you were redirected too, and what if anything happened when you got there. We’d also like to know the browser and device you were using at the time.

As I’ve said before irritating ads make up a tiny fraction of the ads served on road.cc but that doesn’t stop them being irritating if you get one which is one of the two big reasons we’re putting so much effort in to our fight against bad ads. The other reason is that we believe that ads work and that they are the best method of funding road.cc anything else - in our view - starts to blur the line between advertising and editorial. So keep on reporting any irritating or intrusive ads and thanks again for all your help so far.

road.cc's founder and first editor, nowadays to be found riding a spreadsheet. Tony's journey in cycling media started in 1997 as production editor and then deputy editor of Total Bike, acting editor of Total Mountain Bike and then seven years as editor of Cycling Plus. He launched his first cycling website - the Cycling Plus Forum at the turn of the century. In 2006 he left C+ to head up the launch team for Bike Radar which he edited until 2008, when he co-launched the multi-award winning road.cc - finally handing on the reins in 2021 to Jack Sexty. His favourite ride is his ‘commute’ - which he does most days inc weekends and he’s been cycle-commuting since 1994. His favourite bikes are titanium and have disc brakes, though he'd like to own a carbon bike one day.

Add new comment

18 comments

Avatar
mdava | 7 years ago
0 likes

I've been using ad-blockers for years, so I had not expereinced any of these issues on road.cc.

 

However, I'm so impressed that you are actually taking action on the sort of unacceptable, irritating ads that I hate that I've whitelisted your site. 

Avatar
Alex26c | 7 years ago
0 likes

Good initiative. I wish more websites did the same thing.

Avatar
Look555 | 7 years ago
1 like

I was looking forward to having a reasonably well working site and turned off Ghostery - which - as well as blocking ads also blocks videos and discussions /comments - also wanting you to get full credit for serving ads and getting compensated for it. Unfortunately one ad from Sky Mobile has scuppered that. It more or less hijacked my session on every page and I reported it 3 times and disabled the video thing as suggested above about half a dozen. If you can let me know that I need only do this the once I'll take the ad blocker off but till then I'll have my boring non video site...

Avatar
Alder | 7 years ago
2 likes

All highly commendable and I tried dropping shields to see what the site looks like. The problem is that the site is as annoying as the ads.

The top menu is too sensitive and activates at the slightest pointer touch meaning the main drop-down menu always obscures the the top articles and I have to drop the mouse below it then back up again or take the mouse a circuitous route so it doesn’t activate the drop-down. FFS, put an activation delay in.

It’s great that you discourage large, animated ads, but your front page at the moment has a large, animated image promoting the front light reviews which is just as annoying as a flashing ad.

The images that zoom in and out every time the pointer goes over them are very annoying. It seems to be a fashion at the moment, but it's style over substance and hopefully it’ll go away soon. Bad website design annoys users just as much as bad ads, and road.cc is pretty annoying.

So I’ve put my shields back up again, and I’ll continue to find articles via RSS and ignore the annoying front page. Having said that, your RSS is also f****d because it interprets all non-alphanumeric characters as html when it tries to find the articles and returns a “page not found” error (I don't have this problem with any other sites). So I only get to read about half of the articles and reviews that look interesting.

Avatar
HarrogateSpa | 7 years ago
0 likes

There are auto-scroll, auto-start video ads for me on every page today, including this one.

Avatar
Mark_1973_ | 7 years ago
1 like

Halfway through reading this article, my screen jumped to the bottom of the page and an annoying video ad started playing on the RHS of the screen. The irony is, this has never happened whilst browsing this site before!

Avatar
MikeOnABike | 7 years ago
0 likes

LOL, I've just got one of those video adds that scrolls the page down and can't be stopped. Part of the voiceover has the word "F**k" in it. 

Edit : after posting video appearead at the top. code is j8mum1uy7kzxz0

Avatar
Goldfever4 | 7 years ago
0 likes

Agree with other comments - situation has improved noticeably over the last few weeks, thanks for working hard at it.

Avatar
Canyon48 | 7 years ago
0 likes

It's got a lot better of the past few weeks - thanks!

Avatar
PhillBrown | 7 years ago
1 like

Perfect - I was going to email to say thanks, but not for this...

But for the annoying video ads... on them, there's now an option on the top left to report the ad and once a reason has been put into the box and submitted, the ad disappears - see screenshots attached

Bad Ads on this page whilst I was trying to type:
j8mromkwjqvw0a
j8mroknvxvi48g

Avatar
ChasP replied to PhillBrown | 7 years ago
0 likes

PhillBrown wrote:

Perfect - I was going to email to say thanks, but not for this...

But for the annoying video ads... on them, there's now an option on the top left to report the ad and once a reason has been put into the box and submitted, the ad disappears - see screenshots attached

Bad Ads on this page whilst I was trying to type:
j8mromkwjqvw0a
j8mroknvxvi48g

Thanks this has just worked for me  1

I've tried a couple of times to report ads on here but never managed to find the code, it still isn't visable to me???

Avatar
CygnusX1 | 7 years ago
0 likes

Tony Farrelly wrote:

Cutting down the number of ad serving channels we use to the one that is the most responsive to the problem.

PS Chapeau to Google AdChoices for being the one channel doing something about it

Avatar
CygnusX1 | 7 years ago
0 likes

Excellent idea. 

I've recently been getting the redirects to the android app store (almost exclusively betting apps) at least daily on my phone. There's no obvious ad that triggers it, and Chrome on the phone doesn't have an inspect element option that I can find, so been unable to report them.

Fortunately for road.cc's ad revenues, I do most of my browsing of the site in the office on IE11.

Avatar
justDave | 7 years ago
0 likes

Good work! I am getting a much better viewing experience now - even on Ios!

 

Avatar
kev-s | 7 years ago
0 likes

Great!!

 

Now can you sort out the scammers trolling the for sale section

 

Road.cc is no longer a place i will advertise stuff for sale due to the shear number of emails i get from scammers

 

For every item ive advertised i get at least 5 scammers emailing me

Avatar
dave atkinson replied to kev-s | 7 years ago
0 likes

kev-s wrote:

Great!!

Now can you sort out the scammers trolling the for sale section

Road.cc is no longer a place i will advertise stuff for sale due to the shear number of emails i get from scammers

For every item ive advertised i get at least 5 scammers emailing me

yup, that's very much on the list too

Avatar
kev-s replied to dave atkinson | 7 years ago
0 likes

dave atkinson wrote:

kev-s wrote:

Great!!

Now can you sort out the scammers trolling the for sale section

Road.cc is no longer a place i will advertise stuff for sale due to the shear number of emails i get from scammers

For every item ive advertised i get at least 5 scammers emailing me

yup, that's very much on the list too

 

 

 

Avatar
carytb | 7 years ago
0 likes

Excellent. 

Latest Comments