I know, I know – local media outlets (and their, ahem, combative comments sections) aren’t normally the go-to place for positive cycling stories, especially those focused on controversial infrastructure projects invariably branded a “waste of money” by frothing motorists.
But Birmingham Live has bucked the trend of the 21st century recently by publishing an article refuting a suggestion made by the Telegraph and the Mail last year that one of the city’s major cycle routes was “barely used” and a symptom of the local authority’s financial “incompetence”.
Last year, the two national papers – bastions of active travel, naturally – ran stories on Birmingham’s cycle highway along the A34 from Perry Barr to the city centre, which claimed that locals have branded it a “shocking waste” just under £10m, while using one photo to allege that the lane “sits empty” with “no use” using it, while causing “gridlock” and traffic chaos for motorists.
“But the A34 highway… is much more than ‘barely used’. In fact, it is one of the most popular cycle routes in the city,” Birmingham Live wrote in an admittedly belated response to the Telegraph’s claims last week.
The site pointed out that, according to data provided by 849 machine learning vision sensors owned and maintained by Transport for West Midlands, an average of 284 cyclists use the route every day, amounting to around 2,000 journeys a week.
That puts the A34 on the Cyclotron cycle counter list just behind Birmingham’s Bristol Road ‘blue’ route (which averages 501 cyclists a day) and the Sky Blue Way in Coventry (385) as the West Midlands’ third most-used bike route.
Cyclists in the comments, meanwhile, noted that – despite the Telegraph’s claims – “traffic chaos” has not been caused by the cycleway, the construction of which did not reduce road capacity for motorists (I’m shocked, shocked I tell ya).
“There would be traffic ‘chaos’ with or without a cycle lane,” wrote localwhinger. “At least now people have some degree of safety when not in their cars, have freedom to choose, and the urban environment is made slightly more pleasant.”
“How many people would drive if Birmingham had one or two safe roads, but to use any of the others was to risk serious injury or death?” added ukpedestrian. “We need many more protected bike lanes and car-free streets so that more people can feel safe while exercising freedom of transport choice. Our roads need to be redesigned so that everyone, not just car owners, can travel on them in safety.”
> New Birmingham cycle lane turned into ‘VIP drivers route’ for Commonwealth Games
“The Cyclotron is a fantastic resource for those of us promoting cycling in Birmingham and the wider region,” Liz Clements, Cabinet Minister for Transport at Birmingham City Council, told Birmingham Live, along with news that a new cycleway on a key route between Smethwick and Birmingham is due to be discussed soon by councillors.
Meanwhile, cycling and walking commissioner Adam Tranter has also promised that 2024 will be a “bumper year of delivery” for cycling infrastructure schemes in the region, with a “raft” of projects set to be rolled out to give people “more choice” in how they travel.
This ‘good cycling news’ angle is quite the jump from previous stories about “useless” cycle lanes in Birmingham, anyway…
> "Bizarre" seven-foot-long cycle lane a "waste of money" critics claim, but council insists it isn't a bike lane
Add new comment
49 comments
It wasn't a pedal: https://www.facebook.com/share/r/gXYC7NcvjYFNWw1L/
With regards to the gouge in Jeff Stelling's car...
How can we be sure it was done whilst he was away from it and the vehicle was parked?
No disrespect to Jeff but a lot of drivers (especially of larger cars) may not notice if they sideswipe something that could cause damage like that.
So in theory it could be self-inflicted.
Wow, 284 cyclists use the cycle lane everyday making it one of the most popular cycle lanes in Birmingham. The most popular cycle lane here in Paris has on average 15,000 cyclists every work day in winter, 25,000 in summer. The UK has a long way to catch up. (Saying that, 20 years ago only nutters would have dared cycle in Paris)
if motorists want to believe a bike pedal can cut through a car like butter then let them
Much like the motorists who think a cyclist tapping /thumping their car with a human hand will damage it...
1.5m is for their protection, not ours.
are you an orang utan? my arms can't reach anywhere near 1.5m
I did get more room on the train tonight
Looking at that hole in the car door which was - apparently - possibly caused by a bike pedal
Could this have been a test ride for a prototype pedal designed to cut those long dog leads that can often be found stretched across the path
If so - can I have the phone number of the company so I can pre-order a pair????
I'm no cheerleader for discs (neutral) but removing and replacing a disc brake wheel is no more difficult than doing so with a rim brake wheel, I should imagine it was getting the through axle out without that wee drill thing the mechanics use that delayed them.
I'm no cheerleader for discs
I am, and I agree that for non-racing uses disc wheels go in really easily. Of course, it's easiest if you up-end the bike and the racers don't want to do that (it's on the road, have to take off the computer etc.
They wouldn't need to remove the wheel - or even stop - if they ran more appropriate tyres. It might cost a couple of watts but that's better than standing around twiddling your thumbs (or a hex key), particularly for a race with gravel sections.
This is not the first time WVA has seen a potential win ride away from him due to a flat tyre - Paris-Roubaix 2023 an obvious example. He was at the front and apparently had the legs to win. His teammate Laporte was also dropped from the lead group due to a puncture in Arenberg.
Having said that, Cycling News reports that he had said that the puncture was due to "a large nail".
Yep he's released a picture of it (screw not nail though he did originally say nail), unless he fancied running Marathon Plus not much you can do to combat this one...
Whilst my shins and the back of my calves (transitioning to and from carrying up stairs, and the occasional al fresco nature break???) know how vicious MTB grippy flats can be, they ain't that gnarly.
What might be able to do such damage to a cars bodywork? Asking for a friend.
A really big old skool tin opener? (one of those where you spike it into the metal, rather than a modern one with the wheels)
A roofing/shingling/shingler's hammer came immediately to mind. I don't know if you have a different name for it in the U.K.
I think they are called drywall hammers in the UK (google throws that up anyway). We dont have many shingled roofs. My dad built a shed with one but I can't think of any others.
What I used to call a lath hammer. Perfect for nailing, denailing and cutting plasterers laths to length without swapping tools. Estwing make a very good one. My favourite (non-cycling related) multi-use tool is a pair of fencing pliers. Vicious.
I don't think even Harrie Lavreysen has the power to do that damage on the upstroke and its a little too high for the down stroke
https://www.007james.com/i/gadgets/aston-martin-db5/tires-slashed.jpg I rest my case......
Rain in Spain - god knows they need it given the lengthy drought they've been suffering.
all these years the pro peleton has been blaming brake discs for injuries, turns out it was pedals all along.
How long will it be before the police are stopping and searching cyclists and then confiscating their pedals?
I'd buy pedals that could do that, then we'd just need a pedalknife sign to wear as a warning to close passers!
In my experience, sharp pedals are far more likely to hit shins than cars
you might need to increase the tension on your spd spring, to stop feet slipping out..
The last cycle that I had with sharp, gnarly pedals on it was a unicycle as you want good shoe/pedal contact for maintaining control of it. I don't think I'd try SPDs as I did try some cut down plastic toeclips and broke a wrist when discovering a lamppost that was hiding behind some foilage (fell off without getting my foot free in time).
Anyone who can ride a unicycle has my respect!
It's easier than you think - just about anyone can learn
I gots to ask. Why to unicyclists ride around grabbing their balls?
Pages