Support road.cc

Like this site? Help us to make it better.

Cyclists call for resignation of hit-and-run councillor (includes video)

Jersey City councillor Amy DeGise failed to stop after striking a delivery cyclist – and only reported the incident six hours later

A councillor in New Jersey is facing calls to resign after striking a delivery cyclist with her car, driving off while the rider lay injured on the road, and waiting six hours to report the incident to the police.

Amy DeGise, a Jersey City councilperson and former chair of the Hudson County Democrats, struck cyclist Andrew Black at a busy junction in the city just before 8am on Tuesday 19 July.

In the video below, captured by street cameras, it appears that Black, an Uber Eats deliverer, rode through a red light before he was hit by DeGise, who doesn’t seem to attempt to avoid the collision or even slow down after striking the cyclist.

After being helped by police at the scene, Black was then taken in an ambulance to the Jersey City Medical Centre. He suffered no serious injuries in the collision, but his bike was destroyed. He has since started a fundraiser to purchase a new bike so he can “get back to work”. 

The day after the incident, a source close to the Democrat politician told the Jersey Journal that DeGise struck her head during the collision and, once she had realised what had happened, she reported it immediately to the police. 

However, that claim has since been proven to be false, as footage released to the press shows DeGise entering the Jersey City Police Department’s West District precinct at 2pm, over six hours after the collision.

A spokesperson for Jersey City said the police crash report had been completed by the time DeGise, who was not required to take a breathalyser or drug test, made her statement.

> Cyclist left "for dead" by hit-and-run postman was his colleague

29-year-old cyclist Black told the Jersey Journal that the six-hour gap between the crash and DeGise’s appearance at the police station made it appear that she had “something to hide”. 

Megan Carolan, a researcher at the National Institute for Early Education Research at Rutgers University and the author of a petition calling for DeGise to resign, said she “felt sick” to learn that the councillor had waited six hours before reporting the hit and run. 

“I think that some folks have really been relying hard on this idea that she did the right thing eventually,” Carolan said.

“Six hours is not doing the right thing. It’s not.

“This man could have been in the hospital. He could have been dead. She had no way of knowing that.”

As part of her petition, which currently has close to 3,000 signatures, Carolan said: “As an at-large member of the council, Councilmember DeGise has the hefty task of representing the full city and the best interests of all its residents.

“By striking and abandoning one of those residents, in a time of crisis, she has shown she cannot be trusted to put the well-being of residents first.

“To hit a constituent and leave them speaks to a deeply troubling level of self-preservation instinct, and one that has no place in public service.”

Yesterday, a rally was held in the city to demand that DeGise step down from her post, following what organisers described as a “callous, immoral, illegal act”.

However, the councillor, whose father Tom DeGise has served as the Hudson County Executive since 2002, has so far resisted calls to resign over the incident.

“Councilwoman DeGise was elected overwhelmingly just a few months ago and she has no intention of walking away from the commitment she made to serve the people of Jersey City,” her spokesperson said.

“Amy recognizes the calls that have been made for additional information and transparency. She would very much like to address this situation more comprehensively, but there is a legal process that must play out first and she will not be making any additional public comment at this time.”

> Cyclist's severed foot found on hit-and-run suspect's car as driver arrested

Jersey City’s mayor Steven Fulop has defended his fellow Democrat, praising her for “proactively” reporting the incident.

“I’m happy that she took some responsibility – although it doesn’t correct what she did – she took some responsibility by going to the police department proactively afterwards,” he said.

“That was the correct move under those circumstances after leaving.”

After obtaining a PhD, lecturing, and hosting a history podcast at Queen’s University Belfast, Ryan joined road.cc in December 2021 and since then has kept the site’s readers and listeners informed and enthralled (well at least occasionally) on news, the live blog, and the road.cc Podcast. After boarding a wrong bus at the world championships and ruining a good pair of jeans at the cyclocross, he now serves as road.cc’s senior news writer. Before his foray into cycling journalism, he wallowed in the equally pitiless world of academia, where he wrote a book about Victorian politics and droned on about cycling and bikes to classes of bored students (while taking every chance he could get to talk about cycling in print or on the radio). He can be found riding his bike very slowly around the narrow, scenic country lanes of Co. Down.

Add new comment

5 comments

Avatar
robike | 2 years ago
1 like

That video looks like she was probably over the speed limit (25mph), and knowing busy people, probably on a cell phone call.  She was probably, deceitfully, contemplating those issues before she went in to report. 

Avatar
hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
10 likes

In a sane world, not stopping to render assistance should be an automatic loss of license and yes, anyone with integrity would resign from a public position

Avatar
Rendel Harris replied to hawkinspeter | 2 years ago
11 likes
hawkinspeter wrote:

In a sane world, not stopping to render assistance should be an automatic loss of license and yes, anyone with integrity would resign from a public position

In most states in the US - don't know about NJ specifically - failure to stop is regarded as not only an offence in itself but also a de facto refusal to provide a breath/blood sample, which is in turn treated as though the driver was tested and found over the limit. Definitely a law that should be introduced in the UK to stop the "Oh I was so shocked I panicked and drove home, when I got there I had a couple of scotches to calm my nerves before I walked back to the scene" defence.

Avatar
ktache | 2 years ago
5 likes

How did she bump her head?

No obvious change in speed, from the impact or braking.

Drivers helmet might have helped there then...

Avatar
RoubaixCube | 2 years ago
13 likes

“That was the correct move under those circumstances after leaving.”

By driving away after hitting the cyclist, she straight up commited a felony. 

Did she move her vehicle to the side of the road to safety before going back and staying with the cyclist? No

Did she immediately make her way down to the nearest police dept and report or hand herself in? No

Did she pull over to call 911 and report striking the cyclist to the police? No

Therefore. She did not do the right thing.

Latest Comments